After Brahms
3 intermezzi for piano
Program Note
An intermezzo is, by definition, music intended to sit between other things, traditionally covering a scene change in the theatre. But during the 19th century, the label was applied to self-contained instrumental pieces. In the same way that Chopin could offer whole sets of “preludes”, so Brahms composed sets of piano pieces almost exclusively labeled “intermezzo”. When pianist Orli Shaham commissioned Avner Dorman to write a Brahms-inspired work, he chose to write three intermezzos of his own. In naming them “After Brahms” he gave the set a title with a richness of allusion: of influence, of homage and of chronology. (As it happens, in this recording After Brahms also functions as a true intermezzo.) The first of Dorman’s intermezzos is most closed indebted to Brahms. The starting point is Brahms’s Op. 118 No. 1, taking over two independent gestures from Brahms’s piece: the descending melodic phrases in the right hand and the fast rising arpeggio pattern in the left. But above this is an expressive, polyrhythmic melody, and in the middle of the texture Dorman adds a “crawling chromatic line.” Knowing Orli’s personality, her curiosity and depth of interpretation, Dorman felt a tremendous freedom to load the music with layers, and he speaks with admiration of her ability to bring them all out without obscuring the phrasing of the piece. It’s as if she enjoys that there’s something in there “banging against Brahms all the time.” In his second intermezzo, Dorman looks to Brahms’s Op. 119 No. 1. The gesture here is a quiet descending arpeggio motif in which each note is held until the right hand is sustaining a full chord. In contrast with the sense of explosive energy of the first intermezzo, this music seems to melt. Like Brahms, Dorman adopts a simple three-part structure, and as in Brahms, the contrasting central section evokes popular music of the day. For Brahms that might have been a waltz; in his own intermezzo Dorman channels the spirit of 21st-century alt-pop. The first intermezzo has a lot of Brahms, says Dorman. The second has less. “The third has no quotation at all, yet the last sounds the most like Brahms and the first the least. So it’s like a journey. The less I quote, the more I can actually be like him. When I quote, I feel like I have to fight him.” Rather than quoting, the third intermezzo adopts the signature gestures of Brahms: the continual descending lines, the suspended lyrical inner voices and the variety of expressive cross-rhythms, so typical of his piano idiom, and, above all, an elegiac and introspective character. Dorman came to realize that, “like a cell adapting to fit its environment,” his voice had adapted to Brahms’s voice in an inadvertent Brahmsian homage. It’s no accident that the third intermezzo sounds “more like Brahms” than the first two! Yvonne Frindle © 2018
Media
Recordings
Movements
- 1. Allegro con molto appassionato · 1:59 Open in YouTube Music
- 2. Delicatamente con molto espressione · 4:25 Open in YouTube Music
- 3. Adagio espressivo · 5:50 Open in YouTube Music
Reviews
-
Dorman’s rethinking of two Brahms intermezzi (Op. 118, No. 1 and Op. 119, No.1) are wildly virtuosic. I will not be able to hear the originals without thinking of Dorman’s clever settings, which were startling at times, but satisfying.
— Susan Miron , The Arts Fuse (2019)
-
Shaham has Dorman's tricky musical shards comfortably beneath her fingers and the opening Allegro, with its dynamic cascading chords that descend to the very depths of the piano was dispatched with deceptive ease. The beauty of the Delicatamente con molto espressione prefigured Satie (with a romantically pulsating interior), while in the empty and discordant final Adagio espressivo, Shaham captured something of the loneliness of the closeted and aging Brahms.
— Clive Paget , Limelight (2017)
-
Rather than a challenging foray into atonal territory, these three pieces made a worthy postscript to Brahms’ output. Full bodied and satisfying, they took both direct and indirect reference from the Brahms piano pieces.
— Fraser Beath McEwing , J-Wire (2017)
-
These three intermezzi, “After Brahms”, were commissioned by American pianist Orli Shaham in 2014 from the composer Avner Dorman. They are three short pieces that have extended the harmonic language of Brahms whilst retaining the style and technical idioms of his music. The first piece is marked Allegro con molto appassionato and has all the power and passion of Intermezzo No. 1 of Op. 118 with a broad and expansive sound and a creeping line of falling semiquavers.
No. 2 is delicatamente con molta espressione and is an exquisite piece of music. Its opening pattern is reminiscent of the falling chords built note by note in Intermezzo No. 1 of Op. 119 and is such a beautiful and expressive piece. Unlike Brahms, the time signature changes in practically every bar, oscillating between 5/16 and 6/16 with a few bars of 4/16 or 7/16 also included. However, nothing ruffles the expressive quality of this piece. The third and final piece, adagio espressivo, has a lugubrious opening with the slowly moving melody in an inner part whilst the ending is more like a Capriccio. Great pieces for advanced students, with No. 2 being particularly special— Angela Fogg , EPTA Journal (2017)
-
Dorman's After Brahms is a standout, especially the thoughtful, intimate and beautiful final movement.
— Best New Releases of July 2015 , Colorado Public Radio (2015)
-
The first of the three movements…took its cue from Op. 118, No. 1, directly quoting that work but subtly adding chromatic colorations, culminating in a coda of atomic force. The second movement, based on Op. 119, No. 1, had a soulful, almost blues feel. The closing Adagio espressivo movement, the only completely original one, was ironically the most Brahmsian of all, beginning with a simple, understated theme that gradually accumulates dissonant harmonization. Shaham was a spectacular advocate for these works, bringing her virtuosity and intelligent musicianship to bear throughout.
— Tim Sawyer , Chicago Classic Review (2015)
Performances
-
2023
-
May 26, 2023Bargemusic — New York, NY, United States of AmericaPerformers: Orli Shaham, piano
-
2020
-
Apr 4, 2020Madison, NJ, United States of AmericaPerformers: Amy Yang
-
2018
-
Mar 11, 2018Performers: Dana Sturm, piano
-
2017
-
Jul 3, 2017Sydney, AustraliaPerformers: Orli Shaham, piano
-
2016
-
Oct 2, 2016Santa Ana, CA, United States of AmericaPerformers: Orli Shaham, piano
-
2015
-
Dec 17, 2015Phillips Collection —Performers: Alon Goldstein, piano; Amanda Heim, saxophone; Orli Shaham, piano; Tessa Lark, violin; Tomer Yariv, percussion
-
May 31, 2015Chicago, IL, United States of AmericaPerformers: Orli Shaham, piano
-
May 16, 2015Elkins Park, PA, United States of AmericaPerformers: Orli Shaham, piano
-
Feb 19, 2015Aspen, CO, United States of AmericaPerformers: Orli Shaham, piano
-
Feb 17, 2015Phoenix, AZ, United States of AmericaPerformers: Orli Shaham, pianoWorld Premiere